ABSOLUTELY you can over improve. I’m so scared of over improving, I almost don’t do anything! But I may just be neurotic because I see so many people over improve their homes and then expect to make every penny back out of the house. I’m kidding of course, but it brings up a valid point. You CAN over improve.
First things first: Improvements are not equal to Maintenance. Many people get these things confused. They think that they spent 10,000 on a new roof 2 years ago that their home is now worth 10,000 more. WRONG. This is called maintaining your property. If a new roof is needed, its your obligation to put one on; if the outside needs painting, you’ve got to paint it. Improvements are upgrades to kitchens or baths, adding a deck or an addition, etc…
When it comes to improvements lets get one thing straight; We fix our homes up the way we want to because we want to make our living spaces more enjoyable. If you want to deck out your kitchen in the latest and greatest, you do it because you want to. Not because you think, I’ll make ALL of this back when I go to sell. Will you make some of it back? Most likely yes, but it depends on when you go to sell. If you spend 20k on a new kitchen and then try to sell a year later, you probably won’t get it all back. I sold a home last year where the seller put almost 10,000 into their only full bathroom. Mind you this was a modest 2 bed home where none of the competition had baths like this. It truly was spectacular. Almost home-a-rama like. Did it allow me to command a bit of a higher asking price. You bet. Did the seller reclaim all that was put into the bath originally? No. My question to them when we went to price the house was; Would you have put the bath in last year knowing you were going to sell this year? They said yes, they enjoyed every minute of the bath. Then I said “you got your money out of it.” You did it because you enjoyed it, not because you thought it would increase your home value by 10K. Of course you always hope, but the reality isn’t always so.
When it comes to your home and recouping money out of it, you never want to be the biggest and best on the block.

